Wednesday, June 5, 2013

UPTET : मुश्किल में उत्तर प्रदेश सरकार की शिक्षक भर्ती नियमावली


UPTET : मुश्किल में उत्तर प्रदेश सरकार की शिक्षक भर्ती नियमावली 




आजकल जिस तरह से फेस बुक पर भर्ती नियमावली की चर्चा चल रही है वह सरकार की भर्ती नियमवाली के लिए नयी समस्या खडी कर रही है ,
फेस बुक के कुछ सदस्यों ने आज के हिंद्स्तान न्यूज़ पेपर की कटिंग डाली हैं जो की सरकार के टी ई टी मार्क्स का वेटेज देने का इशारा करती हैं -
See






कुछ समय पहले उत्तर प्रदेश सरकार ने टी ई टी परीक्षा को सिर्फ पात्रता परीक्षा करार दिया था और शिक्षक भर्ती नियमावली संसोधित कर दी थी ।

लेकिन इलाहबाद हाई कोर्ट की ट्रिपल बेंच ने एन सी टी ई की १ १ फरवरी २ ०१ १ का हवाला देते हुए कहा की टी ई टी परीक्षा के अंको की उपेक्षा करने न  करने की बात कही है  है और एन सी टी ई को भर्ती मानक तय करने वाला बताया है और राज्य सरकार एन सी टी ई के नियमों का पालन करने को बोला  है , see -
To See Triple Bench Decision , Click Here -

To Read Complete Judgement of Triple Bench , Click Here -


We wish to clarify that the binding effect of the notifications and the guidelines is such that the weightage which is contemplated under the guidelines dated 11th February, 2011 cannot be ignored. The minimum score that is required of a candidate is 60% to pass the teacher eligibility test. A concession of 5% has been made in favour of the reserved category candidates including the physically challenged and disabled persons.
This norm therefore cannot be diluted. Apart from this, the State Government has to take notice of the fact that weightage has to be given in the recruitment process as well. It is for the State Government to suitably adopt the said guidelines and we do not wish to add anything further at this stage as we are only concerned with the essentiality of the qualification of the teacher eligibility test to be possessed by any candidate aspiring to be appointed as a teacher. 

We wish to make it clear that the law has to be followed in the manner in which it has been legislated. It cannot be diluted on account of the inaction of the State. In such circumstances all teachers whose appointment relate to the period after 23.8.2010 have to be possessed of TET.


NCTE Guideline dated 11 February 2011 is -http://www.ncte-india.org/RTE-TET-guidelines[1]%20(latest).pdf
 9(b) should give weightage to the TET scores in the recruitment process
however, qualifying the TET would not confer a right on any person for recruitment/employment as it is only one of the eligibility criteria for 
appointment

टी ई टी अंकों के  सुधार  / वृद्धी   हेतु  , अभ्यर्थी पुन : परीक्षा  में   बैठ  सकते -
See :
Frequency of conduct of TET and validity period of TET certificate :-
11 The appropriate Government should conduct a TET at least once every year. The Validity Period of TET qualifying certificate for appointment will be decided by the appropriate Government subject to a maximum of seven years for all categories. But there will be no restriction on the number of attempts a person can take for acquiring a TET Certificate. A person who has qualified TET may also appear again for improving his/her score



हमारे ब्लॉग ने शुरू से एन सी टी ईकी इस गाइड लाइन को बताया था जिसमे -
१. अभ्यार्थीयों को टी ई टी परीक्षा में पुन : बेठ कर अंक सुधारने की बात है
२. टी ई टी परीक्षा के मार्क्स को नियोक्ता द्वारा चयन में शामिल करने को बोला  है

इलाहबाद हाई कोर्ट ने अपने एक निर्णय में टी ई टी मेरिट से भर्ती एन सी टी ई नियमो के विरुद्द नहीं माना था
http://naukri-recruitment-result.blogspot.in/2012/01/uptet-petition-against-selection-on.html

अब भर्ती  मामला इलाहबाद हाई कोर्ट की डबल बेंच में दोबारा चला गया है जहाँ अकादमिक मेरिट से भर्ती व टी ई टी मेरिट से भर्ती  के विवाद का फेसला होना है ।

Triple Bench also told -
TET exam is good for Uniform Evaluation  (Ek Samaan Mulyankan) of Candidates from different stream.
See -

There also the word qualification came up for consideration and the apex court after having noticed the requirement came to the conclusion that there has to be a uniform scrutiny of all the candidates as they are possessed of educational and training qualifications from different sources. 

The eligibility test therefore is to ensure that candidates coming with diverse educational and training qualifications acquired from different sources are assessed uniformly for the purpose of being selected as the best material for being appointed as a teacher. This is another essential ingredient of a eligibility test, which has been designed as in the present case to ensure an even method of selection. It is for this reason that the curriculum of the teacher eligibility test at the national level has been prescribed by the National Council for Teacher Education for it being implemented throughout the country. It is therefore not only to get the best available candidates for teaching but also to ensure a uniform pattern throughout the nation for employing teachers to provide quality education at the elementary level. 


TRIPLE BENCH appreciate contents of TET exam which is specific to handle children at basic  education level.
The next is the structure and content of the test which has five sections in relation to examination for Classes 1 to 5 with which we are presently concerned. These five sections are Child Development and Pedagogy, Language 1 - focussing on proficiency relating to medium of instruction, Language 2- an optional language, Mathematics and Environmental Studies. The test items for the last two subjects should be correlated with concepts of problem solving ability and pedagogical understanding of the subject. 

The scheme of the said examination therefore is not limited to one particular course of study like an individual subject or a B. Ed. Course. The argument of Sri Agrawal was to compare the curriculum of the higher educational qualifications possessed by a candidate under Clause 3 of the Notification dated 23.8.2010 to indicate that it is inclusive of everything that may be required of a teacher and which qualification has been acquired by a due process, recognised in law. Having perused the curriculum as enumerated hereinabove, we have no doubt that the structure and content of the teacher eligibility test is of a comprehensive character not narrowed down to any individual subject but relates to the overall performance of a candidate to test his capacity and attribute as a teacher. The curriculum therefore cannot be compressed so as to be compared with the claim of possession of a higher qualification of graduation or a B. Ed. Degree


The subject of Child Development and Pedagogy assumes importance and consequently a teacher eligibility test no longer remains a mere eligibility test but becomes the most essential qualification to be possessed for being appointed as a teacher. The word Pedagogy is derived from the word Pedagogue. It originates from the combination of two Greek words, Piados which means Boy and Agogos which means leading or guiding. In ancient times a Greek Slave who was charged with the care of his master's child in his youth with a job to escort the child, to and fro, from school, was known as a pedagogue. Slowly with the passage of time the said word came to be adopted as a synonym for a person who taught in a class room, and was a tutor as he was supposed to lead or guide a child. Thus Pedagogy came to be acknowledged as a science that related to the skill of teaching. It became a scientific art and was developed for the very purpose and aim of Child Development.

Many children are victims of apathy and wrongly motived parental treatment. Their emotional and skilful assessment, and proper treatment, has to be handled within the clinic of an elementary school where the sole physician is none else than a trained teacher. A candidate possessing a mere educational or a training qualification without any genuine attribute may not necessarily be a good teacher

कुछ लोग इस भर्ती को सपा सरकार वर्सस मायावती सरकार वर्सस केंद्र सरकार बता रहे हैं
वैसे देखा जाये तो इस भर्ती में तीनो सपा, बसपा व कोंग्रेस का सम्मिलत रूप दिखाई देता है -
पुराना भर्ती का विज्ञापन बसपा सरकार ने निकला , कोंग्रेस या केंद्र सरकार एन सी टी ई की नियमावली /आर टी ई एक्ट के तहत भर्ती नियम /सैलरी का हिस्सा देने के तोर मोजूद है , और सपा या वर्तमान सरकार इस भर्ती को नए सिरे से पूरा करने के तोर पर मोजूद है ।
आर टी ई एक्ट में बताया गया है कि सर्व शिक्षा अभियान के तहत होने वाली भर्ती में राज्य व केंद्र सरकार दोनों की सहभागिता होगी

25 comments:

  1. agar sarkar ko tet ka weitage dena hota to CTET ke entry kuyn samil karti . eska saaf matlab hi ki TET ka weitage nahi degi

    ReplyDelete
  2. bharti panel mai tet merit walo ko bitha do.

    ReplyDelete
  3. TET wale ko bye bye kaunki bharti academic base par he hogi yeh hum sab jante he inka dimak kharab ho gaya he... jai academic merit jindabad...jindabad

    ReplyDelete
  4. chahe acadmic merit se ho ya tet merit se ho kak se kam bharti to suru ho

    ReplyDelete
  5. Kisi bhi merit ke hazar baar jay karne se kuchh nahin hoga kyoki triple bench ke 52 page ke faisle mein page 43 ko dhyan se study karo to tumhe judges ke rujhaano ka pata chal jayega unhone saaf kaha ki ncte ki guidelines mein tet ko weightage dene ki baat kahi gayi hai to koi bhi rajya sarkaar usko undeka nahin kar sakti hai is baat ke kya maayne hai aap khud hi andaja laga sakte ho vaise bhi harkauli ji ke stay ka aadhar bhi base of selection ko lekar laga hai kyonki unka manna that ki agar koi nai sarkar ka gathan hota to wo manchahe tarike se base of selection change nahin kar sakti hai ab to aap sab academic samarthak bandu samajh hi gaye honge ki kon si merit se selection hona tay hai.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Kisi bhi merit ke hazar baar jay karne se kuchh nahin hoga kyoki triple bench ke 52 page ke faisle mein page 43 ko dhyan se study karo to tumhe judges ke rujhaano ka pata chal jayega unhone saaf kaha ki ncte ki guidelines mein tet ko weightage dene ki baat kahi gayi hai to koi bhi rajya sarkaar usko undeka nahin kar sakti hai is baat ke kya maayne hai aap khud hi andaja laga sakte ho vaise bhi harkauli ji ke stay ka aadhar bhi base of selection ko lekar laga hai kyonki unka manna that ki agar koi nai sarkar ka gathan hota to wo manchahe tarike se base of selection change nahin kar sakti hai ab to aap sab academic samarthak bandu samajh hi gaye honge ki kon si merit se selection hona tay hai.

    ReplyDelete
  7. As I think, bharti prakriya me jo bhi deri ho rahi hai.uski vajah hai,sarkar ke pas dimak ka na hona.m i right? Think!

    ReplyDelete
  8. ABHI TAK LOGO KA TET KA BUKHAR UTARA NAHI HEIN

    ReplyDelete
  9. KOI JUTH PACHAS BAR BOLNE SE SUCH NAHI HOTA SUCH APNE DIL PAR HATH RAKH KAR POOCHHO JAI ACADEMIC

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  12. i respect you mr dinesh but please respect to tet supporters too.

    ReplyDelete
  13. SUSHIL JI EK TET HI HEIN JISKI WAJAH SE HUM AUR AAP IS BLOG SE JUDE HUEIN HEIN LEKIN KISKO SUPPORT KARNA HEIN KISKO NAHI YE INDIVIDUAL KA ADHIKAR HEIN HA ACADEMIC WALE AGAR KISI DUSRE DESH KE HOTE THO MEIN BHARTIYA HONE KE NATE TET KO SUPPORT KARTA but from my opinion academic is better option then tet KYUKI ISSE PAHLE BHI ACADEMIC PAR BHARTI HUI HEIN THO YE BHI HONI CHAHIYE AUR RAHI BAAT TET KI AB THO BED WALO KO PRIMARY WALE UPTET OR CTET MEIN ELIGIBLE BHI NAHI BANAYA HEIN AUR IS TET KA KOI FUTURE NAHI so its better to use this opportunity by academic otherwise these vacancy will filled by tet qualified btc candidates AUR AAP DEKH HI RAHE HO AAJ KAL KITNE PRIVATE COLLEGE KO SARKAR NE BTC KE LIYE MANYATA DE DI HEIN ISSE BTC WALO KI SANKHYA BADHTI HI JA RAHI HEIN YE BTC WALE KOI AUR NAHI ACADEMIC WALE HI HONGE KYONKI BTC KA CHAYAN ACADEMIC KE ADHAR PAR HI HOTA HEIN so time to use brain not think from heart

    ReplyDelete
  14. DINESH DABAS JI AAP KAHTE HAI KI PAHLE ACADEMIC MERIT KE AADHAR PAR SELECTION HOTE THE APKI BAAT BILKUL SAHI HAI KINTU PAHLE TET MERIT KI VYAVASTHA NAHIN THI AUR GOVT KE PASS EK MATRA VIKALP ACADEMIC MERIT THA KINTU AB TET KE ANIVARYA HO JAANE SE TEACHER SELECTION KA EK ACHCHA VIKALP AA GAYA HAI JISSE UTTAM TEACHERS DESH KO MILENGE TRIPLE BENCH KE JUDGES NE BHI KAHA HAI KI TET MERIT KE WEIGHAGE KO KOI BHI RAJYA SARKAR ANDEKHA NAHIN KAR SAKTI HAI VAISE BHI YEH MAMLA DOUBLE BENCH MEIN VICHARDHIN HAI AUR JUDGES HUMSE JYADA KANOON KE BAARE MEIN JANTE HAI LEKIN MAIN EK BAAT SPAST KARNA CHAHOONGA KI JAB KOI ACHCHA PRODUCT AATA HAI TO SAB LOG USKO APNA LETE HAI JAISE PAHLE BAAT KARNE KE LIYE LANDLINE PHONE KA USE KARTE THE AAJ MOBILE KA USE KARTE HAI KOI YEH NAHIN KAHTA HAI KI BHAI PAHLE TO HUM LANDLINE KA USE KARTE THE HUM TO USI KA USE KARENGE MOBILE KA USE NAHIN KARENGE AUR.ACADEMIC MERIT KI SABSE BADI KAMI YAH HAI KI YAH SABHI BOARDS/UNIVERSITIES/SYLLABUS/MARKING PATTERN AADI KI DHYAN MEIN RAKHE BINA SABKO EK HI TARAJOO MEIN TOL DETI HAI .

    ReplyDelete
  15. SUSHIL JI BTC KI MERIT MEIN YE BOARD AUR UNIVERSITY NAHI AATE KYA JAB BTC MEIN ACADEMIC MERIT USE HOTI HEIN THO VBTC MEIN BHI YAHI HOGI DONO LOG PADHANE KE LIYE JAYENGE THO EK HI SCHOOL MEIN EK SAMAY MEIN EK HI TECHNOLOGY CHALEGI agar incoming free hogi tho sabhi customer ke liye hogi na ki kevak ek ke liye

    ReplyDelete
  16. DABAS JI BTC AUR VBTC KO CHHOD DIYA JAYE TO KAHIN PAR BHI AISE VYAVASTA NAHIN JAHAN PAR ACADEMIC KI BASE PAR SELECTION HOTA HAI CHAHE KISI BHI JOB KE SELECTION KO UTAKAR DEKH LO PHIR JAB AAP ITNE BADE ACADEMIC KE SAMARTHAK HO TO UN SELECTION COMMITTEES KO BHI ACADEMIC MERIT KE FAAYDE BATA DO KYA JAANE VE BHI APKI BAATO SE SANTUSHT HOKAR IAS/ PCS JAISE EXAMS MEIN PRE/MANIS/INTERVIEWS KE ESTHAN PAR ACADEMIC BASE PAR HI IAS/PCS BANANA SHURU KAR DE.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Sushil ji kahi bhee asa apne dekha he ki primary teacher ki bahrti TET base par hui ho, Ex- Haryana, Bihar,MP,AP, or UP also.

    Fir is bar kaise ye bharti TET base par ho sakte he jabki govt & court janta he ki TET me Dhandali hui he and kai high rank officer jail ki hawa kha rahe he, fir kaise ye possible he ki bharti TET base par ho sakte he, second yadi bharti TET base par hote he to mayawati wale sabhi rule follow hone chaiye Ex - 50% for girls & 50% for Boys,50 % for science & 50% for arts, and then reservation.if some body have any abjection please revert.

    ReplyDelete
  18. tet merit sai bharti honi chhiyai kyoki barti kai shamay tet merit ki bat hui thi
    tet sai bharti honai per high school inter aur board ka janjat bhi nahi hog

    ReplyDelete
  19. BTC PRIVATE COLLEGE SAI KAR SAKTAI HAI KYA

    ReplyDelete

To All,
Please do not use abusive languages in Anger.
Write your comment Wisely, So that other Visitors/Readers can take it Seriously.
Thanks.